Top 9 Best Substitutes for Pectin

Best Sugar Substitutes for Ice Cream

Welcome, fellow food lovers! As regular readers know, I’m always excited to explore new ingredients and techniques in the kitchen. Preserving seasonal fruits into delicious jams, jellies, and more is one of my favorite passions.

However, I know that relying on store-bought pectin powder isn’t always possible or practical for many home cooks. It can be expensive when purchased regularly, and it isn’t always in stock locally. Additionally, some people have dietary restrictions or allergies to consider.

This got me thinking: as with other foods, there must be natural alternatives we can use to get the thickening and gelling benefits of pectin. After doing some research in my cookbooks and favorite food blogs, I discovered a truly amazing variety of substitutes worth sharing.

In this article, I aim to be your guide to crafting beautiful preserves without commercial pectin, so you too can enjoy this time-honored practice. We’ll cover easy-to-find options as well as more unusual ingredients you may not have tried. I’ll also provide tips on choosing the best fit based on your recipe needs and taste preferences. So let’s get started exploring the wonderful world of pectin substitutes. What are you waiting for? Start preserving!

Homemade Alternatives

Making Your Own Pectin Concentrate

One of the best substitutes has to be making pectin from something I’m sure you already have—tart green apples! It may sound laborious, but the process really isn’t too bad and allows you to control what goes into your food.

Here’s what you’ll need to do:

  • Cut up about 1 pound of underripe, firm green apples and place them in a pot with 2 cups of water. More apples? Add proportionally more water.
  • Bring the apples to a boil, then reduce the heat and let them simmer for 20–30 minutes until soft.
  • Allow the mixture to cool completely before straining through a fine-mesh sieve or cheesecloth overnight. This allows the pectin to separate from the pulp.
  • Discard the used pulp and return the collected liquid back to the pot.
  • Boil on the stovetop, stirring frequently, until reduced by half. This concentration process takes 1–3 hours.
  • Once reduced, you can either use the homemade pectin concentrate right away or store it in sterilized jars in the fridge for up to a week. For every 4 cups of fruit I plan to preserve, I use 1 cup of this homemade concentrate.

Isn’t that simpler than buying a store variety? Let me know if you give it a try! I find the subtle apple flavor it adds quite tasty, too. And you may never need to purchase pectin again.

Plant-Based Thickeners


This ubiquitous kitchen staple proves its versatility as a pectin substitute. Cornstarch contains glucans and mannans that suspend fruit mixture solids to deliver a smooth, jam-like texture.

To use, start by mixing 2 tbsp cornstarch into 4 cups of cooked fruit filling. Bring to a full boil while stirring constantly, then remove from the heat. This helps alleviate any chalky texture and cook off starchy flavors. Make sure to monitor closely as it can scorch.

Cornstarch remains my go-to for lighter preserves like lemon curd or fruit butters when I want a soft set. It dissolves easily and doesn’t alter the filling’s bright flavors. A reliable plant-based option!

Chia Seeds

These nutritional powerhouses contain soluble fiber that forms a protective gel around fruit solids when soaked. No cooking required – just start by simmering your filling until thickened, then stir in 1-2 tbsp chia per cup of fruit and let set up.

I appreciate chia’s ease but find the gel has a sticky, jelly-like mouthfeel different than traditional jam. It works well swirled into yogurt or oatmeal but may not satisfy those craving something spreadable. Still worth experimenting with in cooked fruit dishes.

Tapioca Starch

Extracted from the cassava root, tapioca flour produces a sturdier set similar to pectin. Mix 1-2 tbsp into hot filling and boil rigorously for 1 minute until clear and thickened.

A little goes a long way with tapioca’s binding power. The texture closely mimics store-bought preserves. It remains my preferred thickener for true preserves meant to be layered onto toast. Convenient and consistently reliable.


This familiar sweetener performs decently as a thickener in a pinch, though it does produce a very sweet result. As fruit naturally contains sugar, simply adding more can induce gelation through the osmotic process.

Start with heating your fruit filling as usual, and periodically check the consistency as you slowly stir in extra granulated sugar, 1/4 cup at a time. The sugar will draw moisture out of the fruit as it dissolves, slowly creating a syrup. This can take some patience, allowing time for the mixture to fully incorporate the sugar between additions.

I find it takes roughly 1-2 extra cups of sugar to achieve a gel with most standard fruit preserves when using this technique. Give the mixture an occasional stir as it simmers gently for 2-3 hours to prevent scorching. Allow to cool completely before assessing the texture.

While not the best option if watching your natural sugar intake, it works in a pinch. Just be aware you cannot control the variable water content inherently influencing how much sugar is truly needed. Do take caution not to over-sweeten. But for those who can indulge, it does work in traditional fashion.

Fruits High in Natural Pectin


When preserving with apples as the main or complimentary fruit, you likely won’t need any added pectin at all. Green apples contain the highest concentration of this natural thickener.

I find that simply coring, peeling, and roughly chopping 2-3 medium apples per 4 cups of other fruit provides enough pectin for a good gel. Grate the apples for an even distribution of their pectin-rich flesh. No additional cooking is usually required.

Crabapples make a fun, decorative addition too if used in their smaller whole forms. Overall, apple mixes yield lovely spreads, perfect for toast or scones.

Citrus Pith

Oranges, lemons, and limes – the membranes surrounding the segments all provide a high dosage of citrus pectin. To extract this, simply remove the zest in large strips and thinly peel away any white pith left behind.

Dice the zest/pith and simmer for 20 minutes in a small amount of water before adding to other fruit fillings at a 1:4 ratio by volume. Its bright notes enhance any citrus jam but steer clear of using too much which can overpower the taste.

Best applied when citrus already feature prominently in a recipe. Always certain to result in a lovely soft set requiring no other thickener. Enjoy experimenting!

Additional Options

Let’s explore a couple more options beyond our core plant-based choices. Remember, versatility in the kitchen allows us to play!


Yes, you read that right—gelatin desserts have a place here too. Mixing 1 package of flavored Jell-O to 6 cups fruit filling introduces a burst of sweetness and tang in just a single step.

I especially love letting children explore this one, watching jelly take toasty form through their eager eyes. Just be aware its artificially synthesized essence isn’t for the most discerning natural palates. Still, does simplify things in a pinch!


The original gelling agent remains a winner for its neutral contribution keeping focus on fresh fruit flavors. Use 1 tablespoon powdered gelatin dissolved in cold liquid per cup of finished preserve.

Vegetarians take note – it comes from animal sources. But following instructions exactly yields guaranteed results. Just activate gelatin in cold liquid first before heating your filling and melded combination gels beautifully. Reliable art!

Always with an open, roaming mind do I approach our kitchens adventures. Surprises await wherever curiosity leads. Now, who’s up for more experimenting?!

Choosing the Best Fit

Here are some tips for choosing the best pectin substitute for your needs:

Consider Your Recipe

Think about the style of preserve – stiff jelly or softer fruit spread. Also factor in any dietary restrictions. Sugar-free recipes may require LM pectin or vegetable thickeners that don’t rely on high sugar for binding.

Check Ingredient Preferences

Do you prefer natural, whole foods or are simpler options fine too? Jell-O works great but some feel artificially tangy essences distract. Consult your tastes!

Weigh Texture Goals

Will fluffy seed chia work or demand something spreadable? Cornstarch yields soft texture versus sturdier gels from tapioca. Experiment knowing your desires.

Evaluate Cost/Convenience

Homemade pectin takes time but saves money long term. Common all-purpose items require minimal stocks.

Test Substitutes Through Trial

Dip toes in experimentation, taking detailed notes on proportions and results. Over time, you’ll nail your go-to based on favorite flavor profiles and routine needs.

With patience and playfulness, discovering personal fit invites both success and fun. I encourage seeing the process as creative journey rather than strict rules. Now go, spread your wings and find vibrant inspiration!


Here are some FAQs about substitutes for pectin:

Do I still need to add sugar if using a thickener other than pectin?

Yes, sugar plays an important role in the gel formation process for most fruit preserves. It draws moisture out of the fruit and interacts with pectin/thickeners to solidify into a spreadable consistency. Follow recipes as written.

Can I use thawed frozen fruit?

While frozen fruits may lack some pectin content after thawing, they can still be preserved successfully. You may need to use a bit more of the chosen thickener to account for waterlogged fruit. Proceed carefully, testing for thickness regularly.

What if my jam is runny after cooling?

Dip a spoon in and tilt the jam so it coats the back. If it runs/sheets off, more cooking is needed. Return to a boil and stir in 1-2 more tbsp of your thickener. Monitor closely and re-test flow after vials warm up.

How do I know the difference between a thick vs. stiff set?

A thick set mounds up on a spoon but is still smooth and spreadable. A stiff set holds its shape on the spoon without easily pouring off. Adjust thickener ratios accordingly for your preferred texture.

Can I use store-bought fruit preserves with no pectin added?

Yes! Many commercially produced jams and spreads are thickened without added pectin through careful cooking, sugar levels, and fruit selection. Just be sure to check ingredients for potential allergens.

Does the type of sugar affect setting?

Generally no, but some report corn syrup or liquid sugars producing softer gels versus granulated varieties. Start with recipe as written and experiment thereafter if texture seems off. Sugar variety alone likely won’t “make or break” success.

Can I freeze or can my substitutes-thickened preserves?

Yes, high-sugar preserves made with pectin alternatives will shelf-stabilize through boiling water canning just like standard pectin recipies. For freezing, leave 1⁄2-inch headspace in jars to allow for expansion. Thawed preserves may be softer in texture on opening but safe when processed properly.

I’m vegan – are there non-animal gelatin options?

Absolutely! Agar agar and carrageenan are common vegetarian gel-formers. Use 1 tsp agar powder or carrageenan strands per 2 cups fruit mixture and boil 1 minute for reliable results. Chia, cocoa, and cornstarch also work well for vegans.

I hope these extra questions help provide more clarity and inspiration for your preserving adventures. Please let me know if any other issues come up – I’m always happy to assist!


We’ve covered so many options, your head must be swimming! Let’s pull together the key takeaways before sending you off to the kitchen.

Recap of Best Pectin Substitutes

For overall ease and reliability, I find cornstarch, tapioca starch, commercial pectin, and apples to be set-it-and-forget-it crowd pleasers. Homemade pectin saves money long-run.

Sugar works in a pinch but brings uncontrollable sweetness. Jell-O adds fun for kids’ creations though less natural for me. Gelatin has its place though not vegetarian.

Chia, citrus pith, and my DIY concentrate offer nutrient-rich twists on tradition. Play here if desiring an alternative or new flavor angle.

Tips for Success

Start any substitute by testing small batches to dial in volumes perfect for your style. Note-take for consistency as seasons and fruits vary.

Cook fillings thoroughly yet gently to activate thickeners without scorching delicate fruit sugars. Monitor closely for doneness.

Cool completely before judging texture so pectins/starches can fully bond. You may be pleasantly surprised come morning!

Now It’s Your Turn – Enjoy!

Whether striving for frugality or just culinary adventure, I hope these options spark your creativity. Please share any creations – photos of gorgeous jars always brighten my day.

Keep exploring new ingredients with an open mind. That’s how we connect with fruits, veggies and each other in this beautiful world. Happy preserving!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like